RAIL TECHNOLOGIES

RAIL TECHNOLOGIES

BOBRN maintenance & problems and their solutions


MAINTENANCE RELATED PROBLEMS OF  BOBR / BOBRN WAGONS AND THEIR SOLUTIONS ”

MAJOR COMPONENT DEFECTS NOTICED DURING MAINTENANCE
  • Breakage of adjustable bushing lug.
  • Breakage of adjustable lever lug.
  • Breakage of door hinges.
  • Bent or broken eye bolts.
  • Door clips bent and its hole elongated.
  • Corrosion of door lips.
  • Breakage of bronze bush.
  • Working out of clevis of turn buckle.
  • Breakage of DOM air cylinder barrel.
  • Grazing of SAB pull rod with door operating connecting rod.
  • Grazing of  turn buckle with door operating shaft.
MAJOR DEFICIENCIES NOTICED DURING POH / NPOH
MAINTENANCE RELATED PROBLEMS
  • The BOBR/BOBRN type wagons are maintenance intensive due to higher rate of failures of components and sub assemblies  of door operating mechanism
  • Maintenance cost is relatively high in comparison to that of other type of wagons due to higher failure rate   and longer repair and maintenance time
  • Lack of easy accessibility and replaceability of components and sub assemblies  prone to frequent failure
  • Effect of operating environment leading to corrosion problems
AREA WISE MAINTENANCE PROBLEMS

WORKING OF THE DOOR OPERATING MECHANISM


DOOR OPERATING MECHANISM
Replacement of adjustable bushing complete for breakage of lug.
  • Dismantling of the full unit ( square shaft, adjustable bushing assembly, bronze bush bearing assembly ) from the wagon by removing the pins and cutting the  rivets.

OXY CUTTING  THE RIBS IN BETWEEN THE LEVER PLATES.


REMOVAL OF THE BROKEN ADJUSTABLE  BUSHING .


FITMENT OF  NEW/SERVICEABLE ADJUSTABLE BUSHING IN THE ASSEMBLY AND WELDING THE RIB.


MOUNTING OF THE ASSEMBLED ADJUSTABLE BUSHING ON THE CENTER SILL OF THE WAGON


  • Changing of adjustable bushing is maintenance intensive which requires more time and man power.
REPLACEMENT OF BROKEN BRONZE BUSHES.
Dismantling of bronze bush bearing assembly by oxy cutting lug and stoppers from the square shaft

REMOVAL OF THE BROKEN BRONZE BUSH FROM BEARING HOUSING.

ASSEMBLING THE NEW/ SERVICEABLE BRONZE BUSH IN THE BEARING HOUSING AND MOUNTING THE SQUARE SHAFT .
RIVETING THE BRONZE BUSH BEARING ASSEMBLY ON THE CENTRE SILL OF THE WAGON AND WELDING  THE STOPPER
\
  • Changing of bronze  bush is maintenance intensive which requires more time and man power

BUSH ECCENTRICITY


BREAKING OF HINGES


WORKING OUT OF SAB PULL ROD 


WORKING OUT OF SAB PULL ROD 

GRAZING OF TURN BUCKLE

ADJUSTMENT OF DOOR OPERATING MECHANISM

Door operating lever correctly adjusted.

      No gap in X and Y end and gap of 0 to 5 mm on one side and no gap on   
       the other side in the central door connecting links.

ADJUSTMENT OF GAP BETWEEN ADJUSTABLE BUSHING LUG AND LEVER LUG
Gap of 14 mm + 5 mm to be maintained  at either end and in central location


ADJUSTMENT OF TURN BUCKLE AND ITS LOCKING
Turn buckle to be properly locked by adjustable bolt after correct adjustment .


SECONDARY LOCK ADJUSTMENT

  • Secondary lock Clarence -  6 to 10 mm gap under air pressure and 0 to 2 mm gap when air is released .


ADJUSTMENT  AND LOCKING OF EYE BOLT


OVERHAULING OF DOM AIR CYLINDER

  • Types of DOM Air Cylinder – 14” & 12”
  • Difference between 14” & 12” DOM Air Cylinder

Component Particulars
14” Cylinder
12” Cylinder
Barrel length
578 mm
630 mm
Piston Dia.
355 mm
305 mm
Piston Rod length
775 mm
870 mm
Stroke length
508 mm
560 mm

There are four  types of DOM Air  Cylinders.
Make wise in service  
1 Hydrodyne Pneumat Pvt. Ltd.
2 Techno Chem Pneumatics Pvt. Ltd.
3 Nucon Industries Pvt. Ltd.
4 Pioneer Engineering Works
The Components of the DOM air Cylinders of different make are not
interchangeable .

AIR CYLINDER IN USE BARRELS  OF DOM



DOM AIR CYLINDER END COVERS

DOM AIR CYLINDERS PISTON

DOM AIR CYLINDER PISTON ROD


DEFECTS NOTICED IN PISTON ROD
The DOM Air Cylinder repair kits     (Rubber items) manufacturer wise   are different which calls for  stocking four different types of   repair kits.

CORROSION / DAMAGE OF DOOR LIPS.



REPLACEMENT OF THE DOOR DUE TO HEAVILY CORRODED DOOR LIPS
  • Dropping   of the complete door assembly from wagon  by removing the hinge pins and eye  bolts.
  • Fitment of new door complete

   
Dropping and refitment of complete door assembly from and to the wagon is  quite cumbersome due to heaviness of  the door assembly and limited space available underneath the wagon .

SOLUTIONS  SUGGESTED
Expeditious implementation of Design   Modifications suggested by RDSO during manufacturing , POH & ROH

  • Adjustable bushing.
  • Lever top lug.
  • Turned buckle clevis.
  • Door plate.
  • Hopper plate.
  • Clevis locking plate.
  • Door hinges.
DESIGN OF COMPONENT TO BE REVIEWED
  • Man operating lever bushing
  • Bronze bush
  • Door clips
  • Additional support for pull rod at SAB end

OTHER  SUGGESTIONS

Ø      Bad workmanship during manufacturing stage should be eliminated .
Ø      DOM air cylinder and its repair kit should be standardized .
Ø      Maintenances instructions for overhauling of DOM air cylinder with list of must change items to be prepared by RDSO for implementation in the work shop.
******************************


Bogie Mounted Brake Cylinder(AIR BRAKES)


AIR BRAKE SYSTEM


Types of Air Brake System
n      Coach Under frame Air Brake System

n      Bogie Mounted Air Brake System
            (All new coaches- Since January 1999)

Coach Under frame Air Brake System



BOGIE MOUNTED AIR BRAKE SYSTEM


Comparative chart of Conventional & BMBC Air Brake System


Items
Conventional
BMBC
Weight reduction (as compared to conventional)
---------------
492 Kg
Braking distance at 110 kmph with 18 coaches
905 m
800 m
No of pins and bushes
102
84
Brake block wear rate
3 cc/kwh
1.325 cc/kwh
Conversion cost from Vacuum brakes
Rs 102064/-
Rs 118001/-

SAB
INBUILT SLACK ADJUSTER OF BMBC
n      Take up and pay out the clearance between the wheel & brake block.

n      Only take up the clearance between the wheel & brake block.

n      The effective length of pull rod is decreased during take up the clearance.

n      The effective length of piston rod is increased during take up the clearance.

n      It maintains a uniform piston stroke through out the formation.


n      The piston stroke of the cylinder is not uniform through out the formation and varies up to 60mm.

n      It does not require adjustment of piston stroke every trip.

n      Every trip the piston stroke require to be adjusted.

n      Spindle is made up of triple start thread.

n      Adjusting screw (spindle) is made up of double start thread.

n      To adjust the slack, the length of the pull rod is increased or decreased during forward stroke.

n      To adjust the slack the length of the piston rod is increased during return stroke.

n      When length of the pull rod increased manually the clearance between the wheel & brake block increases.

n      When the effective length of piston rod is increased manually, the clearance between the wheel & brake block decreases.





Difference between SAB & Inbuilt Slack Adjuster of BMBC


Necessity of Bogie Mounted Brake System (?) 

Necessity (?)
n      The SAB slack adjuster used in the underframe mounted brake system has limited vendors.

n      The total brake force is in the order of 100% of the tare weight and therefore the brake linkages are heavily loaded resulting in frequent maintenance demands on brake beam, brake head, brake gear pins and bushes.

n      The brake pull rod is supported by spring loaded nylon rollers which wears out very fast. Thus it becomes inefficient unless the nylon rollers are changed regularly.
n      Breakage of pull rod (of SAB) also occurs due to bending while negotiating the curves


n      The components like support brackets, pins and bushes, pull rod and support for pull rod provided on the under frame increases additional weight of the coach.

n      Vibration of the pull rod during running cause rattling noise.

Design Features of Bogie Mounted Brake Cylinder

n       External slack adjusters have been eliminated.Total four nos. of 8” (203.2 mm) size brake cylinders (two per bogie) are used in place of two 14” (355 mm) size under frame mounted brake cylinders in standard air brake.

n       Each cylinder is provided with built-in single acting slack adjuster to take up the clearance automatically between wheel and brake block whenever the clearance increases due to wear on the brake block and the wheel and the maximum slack take-up is 305 mm.

n       These cylinders are mounted between central longitudinal members connecting the bogie transom and the headstock on either side.
n       Each cylinder controls the braking of wheels of each axle. Piston stroke is 32 mm.

n       Provided with less number of brake fittings, therefore, easy to maintain.

n       High friction ‘K’ type composite brake blocks are used, whose life is 5-6 times more than that of cast iron brake blocks.
n       Unusual noise on run is completely eliminated.

n       Use of curved pull rod with additional hole for manual
n       The overall weight saving per coach is about 492 kg.

n       Number of pins and bushes reduced from 102 to 84.

n       Braking distance has come down from 905 mm to 800 mm.


Working Principle of BMBC

There is no change in the pneumatic system of the brake for bogie-mounted arrangement compared to underframe mounted brake. The system will respond to action of A-9 valve in similar fashion as in the case of standard air brake system during brake application and release.
                                                or
            There is no change in the overall brake system in bogie mounted arrangement up to the action of DV.
Brake Application
Compressed air is admitted to brake cylinder between piston and cylinder body forces the piston trunk assembly to move outward against the force of release spring.  The brake force is transmitted through the trunion body, adjusting screw, adjusting tube, cross head, brake rigging and finally to the brake blocks.

Brake Release
When the compressed air from brake cylinder is vented the release spring moves the piston trunk sub-assembly to release piston.  As soon as the piston stroke exceeds (32 mm) during return stroke the adjustment (in built-in one way slack adjuster) takes place

Manual Adjustment of BMBC
A red paint mark on the adjusting tube sub-assembly indicates that the piston unit has extended over its full range and requires re-setting. The design of the brake-rigging unit is done in such a way that range of slack adjuster covers the life of brake blocks so that re-setting and replacing brake blocks will be done at the same time.
Procedure of Manual Adjustment

n      Disengage the cross head from the adjusting tube, by pulling the latch.

n      Turn the adjusting tube clockwise to decrease the length of the adjusting tube (Effective length of piston rod).

n       After replacing the brake blocks, apply to brake and check the piston strokes.

n      If piston stroke is correct, engage the cross head with the resetting plate by releasing the latch.

n      If the piston stroke is less, decrease the length of adjusting tube to increase to clearance between wheel and brake block.

n      If the piston stroke is more, increase the length of adjusting tube to decrease the clearance between wheel and brake block.

n      After adjusting the piston stroke, ensure the cross head is locked with adjusting tube with the latch.


Components of Bogie Mounted Brake Cylinder


Functions of Main Parts Adjusting Screw
n      The function of adjusting screw is to move the adjusting tube forward to increase the effective length of the piston rod automatically or to decrease the effective length of the piston rod manually.

n      The adjusting screw is connected with a ratchet and forms a single unit. The adjusting screw is provided with a pitch of 1/8’’ (3.15 mm). The ratchet is provided with 18 teeth.

n      When the adjusting screw completes one full rotation it makes adjusting tube to move forward or backward by 2X3.15 mm = 6.30 mm.

n      If the ratchet is moved/rotated by one tooth, the adjusting screw is rotated by 360 degree/18 =20 degree, which in turn moves the adjusting tube outward/inward by 6.30/18 mm = 0.33 mm (1/72 “).

nFrom the above, it is clear that to move the adjusting tube forward automatically by 1”, it requires 72 return strokes.
Functions of Main Parts Rocker Arm
n     
The rocker arm is fitted with piston head by means of shackles and it moves along with the piston head.

n      The roller end of the rocker arm slides over the roller plate and the other end of the rocker arm rests on the pawl housing through plunger pin.

The roller plate is fixed at an angle with the front cover by means of bolts. The function of roller plate is to displace the pawl housing vertically when the rocker arm moves horizontally. It converts the linear displacement of rocker arm into vertical displacement of pawl housing.
Functions of Main Parts Pawl-Housing Ring
n      The pawl-housing ring is pivoted with the pivot pin of turnion body at one end and the other end of the pawl housing ring moves/turns freely. A spring-loaded pawl is housed at the free end of the pawl housing. At the bottom of the pawl housing a spring loaded plunger / sleeve is kept between the turnion body and the pawl housing to move the pawl housing upward during forward stroke. At the top, a plunger is kept between the rocker arm and the pawl-housing ring to move the pawl housing downward during return stroke.
Functions of Main Parts Pawl-Housing Ring
The function of the pawl housing and the pawl is to move /turn the ratchet by one tooth whenever the piston stroke exceeds 60 mm to increase the effective length of the piston during return stroke

 Slack Take – up Action
Piston stroke exceeds a predetermined value ( on account of wear of either brake block or wheel or both), a ratchet with adjusting screw fitted insides the cylinder turns thereby increasing the effective length of the piton rod AUTOMATICALLY.
How does the Effective length of Piston Rod increase automatically ?
 Maintenance Instructions of BMBC

n      Ensure high friction composition brake block (K-type) be used.

n      Do not mix up the levers used in the brake gear for AC & Non-AC coaches in storing.

n      Do not mix up the curved profile pull rods used in the brake gear for AC & Non-AC coaches in storing.

n      Use extreme holes of the curved profile pull rods for the assembly of brake gear for the wheel diameter up to 839 mm.

n      Use inside adjacent hole of the curved profile pull rods for the assembly of brake gear for the wheel diameter below 839 mm. In addition, provide 38 mm packing plate at the axle box to maintain buffer height.

n      Replace all brake blocks those fitted with the part of the wheel set when RED MARK provided on the adjusting tube of the corresponding brake cylinder is visible.

n      Replace the brake blocks as wear in each block reaches the IDENTFICATION MARK of condemnation.


WORKING OF JSL TYPE BOGIE MOUNTED BRAKE CYLINDER WITH IN-BUILT SLACK ADJUSTER


PROBLEM WITH U/F MOUNTED BRAKE SYSTEM

         SAB slack adjuster used in the under frame mounted brake system has limited vendors
         Rattling of pull rod in under frame mounted brake causes noise during running
         rake linkages are heavily loaded resulting in frequent maintenance demands
         Considerable coach days are lost
         The brake pull rod is supported on the spring-loaded nylon rollers that wear out very fast
         The components like support brackets, pins and bushes, pull rod and support for pull rod provided on the under frame mounted brake system increases additional weight on the coach
INTRODUCTION OF BMBC
In order to overcome the problems of slack adjuster failure as well as problems associated with cast with ‘K’-type high friction composite brake blocks has been introduced Indian Railways has switched over to Bogie mounted air brake system on coaching stock from January 1999 iron brake blocks, a design of brake system incorporating 8" size two cylinders on each bogie along




 N.Ramjee.
Junior Engineer
Carriage & wagon
vskp/E.Co.rly/Wat.